Will Washington, DC, Become The 51st US State?

By

CCSS NCSS-5 810 Words 6-Minute Listen
The bill to make DC a state was approved in the US House of Representatives on April 22, 2021 (Credit: YouTube screen capture)

On April 22, 2021, for the second consecutive year, the US House of Representatives voted 216-208 to make Washington, DC, the nation's 51st state. Though the symbolically titled H.R. 51 bill is identical to the one passed on June 26, 2020, the legislation was never put to the vote in the then Republican-controlled Senate. However, this time around, the bill — which has the support of both President Joe Biden and Democratic Majority Leader Charles E. Schumer — will get a hearing in the upper house of Congress.

Why is Washington, DC, a district?

Washington. DC, is designated a district under the legislation of the US Congress by the US Constitution (Credit: Pixabay/CC0)

The US Constitution stipulates that the seat of the U.S. government should be a “District" (not exceeding 10 square miles) over which Congress would “exercise exclusive legislation in all cases whatsoever.” The measure was placed to ensure that no single state could yield unfair power for playing host to the national government.

To maintain neutrality, the District of Columbia Organic Act of 1801 stripped residents of their rights to vote in all federal elections, including for president. The 23rd Amendment, ratified in 1961, restored all voting rights. However, it stipulates that regardless of its population growth, DC can not have more electoral college votes than the nation's least populous state — Wyoming, which has just three electors.

In 1973, DC residents were finally allowed to elect a local government, comprising a mayor and a council. However, the US Congress continues to have the authority to modify and review the city's budget and overrule any law it doesn't like. As a result, despite paying more federal taxes per capita than residents of any other US state, the 700,000 people in the nation's capital city are at the mercy of the lawmakers. The residents also have no formal representation in the Senate and only a non-voting House Delegate, which means they have no designated lawmaker to advocate for them in Congress.

Proponents of H.R. 51 believe that all these issues will be resolved if DC is made a state. "For far too long, the more than 700,000 people of Washington, D.C., have been deprived of full representation in the U.S. Congress," a statement from the White House Office of Management and Budget said. "This taxation without representation and denial of self-governance is an affront to the democratic values on which our Nation was founded."

Would making DC a state require a Constitutional amendment?

Two square miles of Wahington DC would be set aside as the seat of the government (Credit: statehood.dc.gov)

Opponents of statehood argue that any change to DC's current status would require a constitutional amendment. However, Eleanor Holmes Norton, the District of Columbia House Delegate, who sponsored the legislation, says H.R 51 does not eliminate the “seat of government" — it merely shrinks it from the maximum 10 square miles allowed by the US Constitution to a smaller, 2-square-mile area. The new "District" would encompass all federal buildings and monuments — including the White House, the US Capitol, the National Mall, and the Supreme Court.

Does a House approval guarantee a vote in the Senate?

Most experts believe a 51st star in the US flag is unlikely for now (Credit: Jacobolus/ Public domain/ Wikimedia Commons)

The House vote, which was strictly along party lines with the Democrats voting for and the Republicans voting against the measure, does not guarantee the bill's passage in the Senate. Though Democrats, who occupy half the seats, can depend on Vice President Kamala Harris's tie-breaking vote, the Senate currently requires at least 60 votes to enact new legislation. Hence for H.R 51 to pass, ten Senate Republicans would have to vote in favor, which is extremely unlikely,

The lawmakers could change the requirement to a simple majority, but that would still require all 50 Democrat Senators to vote in favor of H.R. 51. On April 30, 2021, Democratic Senator Joe Manchin III of West Virginia, told a local radio station that he would not vote for DC statehood. “If Congress wants to make DC a state, it should propose a constitutional amendment,” Manchin said. “Let the people of America vote.”

Fellow Democrat Senator and former astronaut Mark Kelly of Arizona is also lukewarm to the idea. “I haven’t made a decision on it one way or the other,” Kelly told Capitol Hill reporters shortly after the House vote. “I’ll make a decision ultimately based on what’s in the best interest of our country.”

The timeline of when the proposal will be considered in the Senate remains unclear. However, most experts believe that even if the bill passes, the battle will be embroiled in the courts for many years. Regardless of the outcome, Ms. Norton is happy with the progress she has made since her first attempt for DC statehood in 1993, when over 100 House Democrats opposed the idea.

If passed, what would the new state be called?

Since we already have a state called Washington, Ms. Norton suggests naming the new addition The State of Washington, Douglass Commonwealth — after the nation's first president and famed abolitionist Frederick Douglass, who lived in DC from 1877 to 1895.

Resources: WashingtonPost.com, NPR.com. Whitehouse.gov, Usatoday.con

Get the Workbook for this article!

Workbook contains: Article, Reading Comprehension, Critical Thinking Questions, Vocabulary in Context (+ answers), Multiple Choice Quiz (+ answers), Parts of Speech Quiz (+ answers), Vocabulary Game (+ answers)
Cite Article
164 Comments
  • no123456789
    no123456789Thursday, May 13, 2021 at 12:28 pm
    olny 50 states plZ
    • furryboi
      furryboiWednesday, May 12, 2021 at 7:52 am
      i want it to be the 51st state
      • wolfieland
        wolfielandWednesday, May 12, 2021 at 7:45 am
        I honestly don't think we need another state, we're doing just fine with just 50 in my opinion. And if they do add another state they are going to need to update litterally every map in the world
        • spookyraptor
          spookyraptorWednesday, May 12, 2021 at 5:53 am
          No. Just please no. 50 is a too iconic number for the US, 51 would ruin everything. This would cost lots of money. They should be focusing on more important things, really. Washington DC is too small for a state. It would ruin a lot of maps, would interfere with other things, and more. This is an awful idea.
          • pig45
            pig45Wednesday, May 12, 2021 at 5:43 am
            Okay the reason the bill was created was because D.C has way to many people living in it. But they can not vote because they are not a state. The thing is it was not a state before because the republicans would not pass it because alot of Washington D.C is democrat. The passing of this bill would be essential to the voting system. For the republicans it means that the democrats will have more supporters. That and the republicans commit voter suppression anyway.
            • sakura_skittles
              sakura_skittlesTuesday, May 11, 2021 at 7:39 pm
              I can barly rember the 50 states rn lol
              • sakura_skittles
                sakura_skittlesTuesday, May 11, 2021 at 7:35 pm
                I dont know but learning the states all ready was hard enough. Its famous enough- that would also mean more money and buissnesses are CLOSING becausse they dont have enough money....I dont like this...
                • rosiek
                  rosiekTuesday, May 11, 2021 at 3:56 pm
                  This is crazy. D.C. is already famous ENOUGH without it being a STATE! :p ;p
                  • sydney_zepp
                    sydney_zeppWednesday, May 12, 2021 at 6:34 am
                    I agree! They really don't need a new state, also.
                  • rainbows1234567
                    rainbows1234567Tuesday, May 11, 2021 at 3:52 pm
                    At would they want a new state! If I were them I would not want a new state!
                    • sydney_zepp
                      sydney_zeppTuesday, May 11, 2021 at 11:19 am
                      Umm, I don't like this... I hope they don't make it a state. A. It would be very a very small state, and B. It is unnecessary, they should be working on more important things... *sighs*